Logic grid No. 8 · Hard · 5 suspects · 12 clues

The Star Atlas

At ten o'clock, a librarian brought the Pellham Library's 1610 star atlas up from the vault to the reader at the east desk. At closing time it was missing. Five readers had signed in that morning. Each sat at a different desk, was researching a different subject and signed in at a different time.

Clues

  1. The reader who sat at the west desk signed in twenty minutes after the reader who was researching astronomy.
  2. Lionel signed in at either 8:50 or 9:50.
  3. Judith signed in earlier than the reader who sat at the center desk.
  4. Lionel signed in earlier than Ira.
  5. The reader who sat at the north desk did not sign in at 9:30.
  6. The reader who was researching astronomy signed in earlier than Lionel.
  7. The reader who was researching heraldry signed in earlier than Hester.
  8. The reader who signed in at 9:50 was researching either astronomy or navigation.
  9. Lionel was not researching heraldry.
  10. The reader who sat at the east desk signed in twenty minutes after the reader who sat at the west desk.
  11. The reader who sat at the south desk was not researching botany.
  12. The reader who was researching heraldry signed in earlier than Judith.

Who sat at the east desk?

Logic grid. Mark a box ✕ when the pair is ruled out and ● when it is confirmed.
Tap a box: ✕, then ●, then clear. Desk Subject Signed in
north east south west center astronomy botany heraldry navigation architecture 8:30 8:50 9:10 9:30 9:50
Name Gideon
Hester
Ira
Judith
Lionel
Signed in 8:30
8:50
9:10
9:30
9:50
Subject astronomy
botany
heraldry
navigation
architecture
Show the answer

Ira sat at the east desk.

NameDeskSubjectSigned in
Gideon northastronomy8:30
Hester centernavigation9:50
Ira eastheraldry9:10
Judith southarchitecture9:30
Lionel westbotany8:50