Logic grid No. 6 · Hard · 5 suspects · 14 clues

The Night Express

A jewel case vanished from compartment D of the night express somewhere between the last two stops. The conductor's sheet lists five passengers in the first-class car. Each had a different compartment, carried one piece of luggage and boarded at a different station. The stations are listed in the order the train reaches them.

Clues

  1. Dr. Dunmore boarded one stop after the passenger who had compartment D.
  2. Mr. Abbott boarded one stop after the passenger who carried a violin case.
  3. Mr. Abbott boarded before the passenger who carried a hatbox.
  4. The passenger who carried a violin case had compartment B or E.
  5. The passenger who boarded at Marston had compartment A or E.
  6. The passenger who had compartment C did not carry a steamer trunk.
  7. The passenger who carried a carpetbag boarded one stop after the passenger who had compartment D.
  8. The passenger who had compartment D did not carry a valise.
  9. Mr. Ellis did not carry a valise.
  10. Mr. Abbott had compartment A or D.
  11. The passenger who carried a valise boarded before the passenger who carried a carpetbag.
  12. The passenger who boarded at Rexford had compartment B or E.
  13. The passenger who had compartment B did not board at Linden.
  14. Miss Carver carried either a carpetbag or a violin case.

Who had compartment D?

Logic grid. Mark a box ✕ when the pair is ruled out and ● when it is confirmed.
Tap a box: ✕, then ●, then clear. Compartment Luggage Boarded at
A B C D E hatbox valise steamer trunk carpetbag violin case Harwick Linden Marston Oakley Rexford
Name Mr. Abbott
Mrs. Bell
Miss Carver
Dr. Dunmore
Mr. Ellis
Boarded at Harwick
Linden
Marston
Oakley
Rexford
Luggage hatbox
valise
steamer trunk
carpetbag
violin case
Show the answer

Mr. Ellis had compartment D.

NameCompartmentLuggageBoarded at
Mr. Abbott Asteamer trunkMarston
Mrs. Bell CvaliseHarwick
Miss Carver Eviolin caseLinden
Dr. Dunmore BcarpetbagRexford
Mr. Ellis DhatboxOakley