Logic grid No. 6 · Hard · 5 suspects · 14 clues
The Night Express
A jewel case vanished from compartment D of the night express somewhere between the last two stops. The conductor's sheet lists five passengers in the first-class car. Each had a different compartment, carried one piece of luggage and boarded at a different station. The stations are listed in the order the train reaches them.
Clues
- Dr. Dunmore boarded one stop after the passenger who had compartment D.
- Mr. Abbott boarded one stop after the passenger who carried a violin case.
- Mr. Abbott boarded before the passenger who carried a hatbox.
- The passenger who carried a violin case had compartment B or E.
- The passenger who boarded at Marston had compartment A or E.
- The passenger who had compartment C did not carry a steamer trunk.
- The passenger who carried a carpetbag boarded one stop after the passenger who had compartment D.
- The passenger who had compartment D did not carry a valise.
- Mr. Ellis did not carry a valise.
- Mr. Abbott had compartment A or D.
- The passenger who carried a valise boarded before the passenger who carried a carpetbag.
- The passenger who boarded at Rexford had compartment B or E.
- The passenger who had compartment B did not board at Linden.
- Miss Carver carried either a carpetbag or a violin case.
Who had compartment D?
| Tap a box: ✕, then ●, then clear. | Compartment | Luggage | Boarded at | |||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | B | C | D | E | hatbox | valise | steamer trunk | carpetbag | violin case | Harwick | Linden | Marston | Oakley | Rexford | ||
| Name | Mr. Abbott | |||||||||||||||
| Mrs. Bell | ||||||||||||||||
| Miss Carver | ||||||||||||||||
| Dr. Dunmore | ||||||||||||||||
| Mr. Ellis | ||||||||||||||||
| Boarded at | Harwick | |||||||||||||||
| Linden | ||||||||||||||||
| Marston | ||||||||||||||||
| Oakley | ||||||||||||||||
| Rexford | ||||||||||||||||
| Luggage | hatbox | |||||||||||||||
| valise | ||||||||||||||||
| steamer trunk | ||||||||||||||||
| carpetbag | ||||||||||||||||
| violin case | ||||||||||||||||
Free printable puzzles and case files at coldcasekit.com/puzzles/
Show the answer
Mr. Ellis had compartment D.
| Name | Compartment | Luggage | Boarded at |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mr. Abbott | A | steamer trunk | Marston |
| Mrs. Bell | C | valise | Harwick |
| Miss Carver | E | violin case | Linden |
| Dr. Dunmore | B | carpetbag | Rexford |
| Mr. Ellis | D | hatbox | Oakley |